In a recent survey by BIE, 43% of respondents felt that the development of specialisms within finance was hindering CFO succession planning.
This highlights a challenge for the future leaders of finance in today’s heavily siloed business environment. They need to find a balance between specialising in a financial discipline and getting broad exposure across all aspects of the function in order to develop more rounded experience necessary to progress to the top.
It is getting harder to find well-rounded finance talent, no matter the organisation or the industry. The talent graduating through larger organisations are very narrow in their experience. Even relatively junior talent often don’t have the skills to look at a balance sheet from top to bottom. Many organisations don’t prioritise training talent internally, so junior team members are not getting the exposure they need in other areas.
Large companies can become highly efficient by employing global functional processes to be consistent, which allows individuals to become fantastic at micro-processes. However, because they become siloed, they don’t necessarily understand the upstream or downstream implications of their processes.
From a career perspective, it is important that individuals have the personal desire to get out and develop themselves within the business. This can be easier in a larger company that has an organisational rotation programme.
However, it should be incumbent upon CFOs to take responsibility for their team members getting around other functions such as FP&A and the commercial side, even if it is only for 12-18 months to get some exposure to different areas where they may have an interest.
The more organisations move towards outsourcing their technical functions, the ability to have someone developing as a highly skilled finance professional, who has the rigour that comes with reconciling the balance sheet, becomes even harder to achieve.
The controllership function is where all technical training should be achieved. So how much of this should be outsourced? Finance business partner or commercial teams can’t be built without knowing that the technical team can interpret a balance sheet and P&L. It can be a powerful engine for the business, that then provides a natural progression into FP&A and beyond.
A lack of understanding and exposure to balance sheets is a serious risk moving forward. 30 years ago, CFOs were looking in the rear-view mirror and focussing on producing the numbers. Now, businesses are looking to the CFO for guidance. The commercial drive and business partnership is fantastic, but useless if the numbers are wrong. And then the function runs the risk of giving bad advice.
Finance business partnering is viewed as a combination of technical and communication skills. But is it more of a behaviour than a skill? The technical side is still very important. It’s often the case that finance business partners have no concept of the balance sheet and are too busy looking at the P&Ls.
The finance business partner relationship needs to work both ways. They are providing support to the business with their financial hat on, but they are also representing finance to the wider business and getting them to think about financial issues. Therefore, for succession planning, if a business partner wants to become a CFO, they need to engage more with the technical side of accounting. They need a full understanding of the whole function. Even if they are not doing it now, they need to understand it to get to the next level.
In our Finance Succession Planning and Transformation Survey 2018, we investigated how organisations are dealing with succession planning within their finance function. To download your copy of the report, click the link below.